Does Canada have strict regulations on employee salaries? If not, employers of journalists would be inclined to pay less over time. In a "free market", the net wages are what matters to accepting a position for the employee.
Likewise, if an independent journalist see net income at a comparable rate to other industries and the bills are paid, in a competitive market they will lower the price of their output to compete.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
To quote the article “We have a government that ‘gets it,’” Deegan said. “They see what Big Tech monopolists have done to local news.
For those who have been alive longer than social media. Local media was destroyed by large traditional media conglomerates that bought up all of the them during the golden era of traditional media. Now that they aren't profitable and are being kept alive by government how will this solve those problems?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Can someone explain why government-funded media is a positive? Some things to consider:
1. What if the government was right-wing and the news produced reflected that - would you still support it?
2. Investigative journalism was birthed in the free market era of yellow journalism, funded by consumers buying newspapers and being served ads - where is this supposed golden age of government funded media that people refer to?
3. For every Fox News, there’s a CNN/MSNBC/. For every WSJ, there’s a WaPo/NYT/LAT/etc. Aka privately funded media results in heavy left wing skew - what’s the gap that government funded media fills?
4. Government funded media is by definition propaganda - that doesn’t concern you?
5. Of the government is paying journalists’ salaries, how does that reduce conflict of interest in holding higher ups accountable more so than for journalists and privately funded outlets? Wouldn’t both be hesitant to go after their respective bosses?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Canadian residents will pay for it substantially via never ending taxes across ever growing facets of life. Big governments will always over spend and accumulate dept.
There is no easy solution. The best is to leave it up to people to choose their sources.
Unfortunately, Canada is moving in wrong directions. Canadians haven't lived in EU to understand where the policies of their government is leading to.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Fiscally speaking Canada is in a much better position than the US with regard to public debt, I think most would agree that the quality of public services is better in Canada than the US.
Not saying the government here doesn't have a problem with overspending, but it's perhaps not as bad as you might think
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
You did not mention the sources of dept. Defense is a major part of it, and that feeds back to the system. For example, the war in Ukraine has raised the public dept in Ukraine and EU significantly. You need strong security to support a strong economy. Part of it is also the status of US dollar as the world currency reserve, which is critical.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
No we need some publicly supported media to get away from the monopolization and consolidation of private ownership and influence on basically all other media.
Just like public ownership of critical infrastructure, it doesn't matter what it costs, we should own it collectively.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Let's flip this to understand your true perspective:
What are some countries where you think they're doing a good job and going in the right direction?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Oh dear god please look at how much taxes people and companies had to pay across the world up until (in Germany) even the 90s!
All the infrastructure decaying today was built with the ample tax revenue back then, until Thatcherism, trickle down and starve the beast crap ideology corrupted everything
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
“Substantial” in this case is less than $3 cad per month.
This isn’t Canada moving in any direction, the CBC has been around and publically funded for decades.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
We have public TV and radio in Slovenia and while I would not call for defunding it, it is an incredibly biased institution and I can't buy that any human institution would be otherwise - we all have a worldview and birds of feather flock together. So while they do keep a more civil level of discourse, they are also incredibly smug and have a superiority complex even though it's not like the journalists they have on the payroll are the brightest tools in the shed. Another issue is that, like every institution that doesn't have to fight to survive, they are incredibly cavalier when it comes to their work ethic and costs. The latter doesn't bother me as much because you can potentially get some brilliant stuff done if everybody leaves you alone (Adam Curtis documentaries on the BBC), the obvious left wing bias, however, is problematic.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Note that this is not funding for public media.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Despite what the article says, funding of journalists is controversial. Im a little disappointed that the article reads like a press release. The controversy comes from the fact that this is not a tax write off open to everyone. You have to be approved by a council that is ultimately appointed by the government. The money comes from big tech aggregators. The second point in the article is that it is not open to companies whose ownership is not separate from news. This means small community outlets are out. It’s really a subsidy to large news corporations. They are afraid of social media and other sources of news people are turning to. It’s potentially about many things but ideological diversity is not one of them.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Good. Public funding of media, public funding of election campaigns and public funding of healthcare… it’s not perfect, but it helps, if the goal is to have a healthy society. Imagine a USA without FoxNews, superPACs and refused patients because of money.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Public funding of healthcare inevitably leads to every choice an individual makes being scrutinized as a possible cost to said healthcare.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
So who counts as a proper "news organization" and/or "journalist" in this scheme?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
A panel of independent reviewers, separated from the government, will make this determination. Presumably, they will establish and publish a rubric.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
A panel of well-connected reviewers, appointed from the government, will make this determination. Presumably, they will establish and publish a nice press release.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
I think the snarky comments about "state owned media" miss the point.
We shouldn't pretend that there's no political risk, no matter if it's structured as a tax break or direct ownership: every time you tie the well-being of journalists to government policy, you inject some bias into the process.
However, journalism as such is not financially sustainable in the era of internet clickbait and AI slop, so you kinda need to subsidize reporting if you want to have any reporting at all. Otherwise, all the local news you're gonna get are gonna be Facebook gossip, fake stories engineered for clicks, and paid PR pieces.
Like, yeah, BBC minces their words when it comes to criticizing government policy, but they can also afford to send real journalists to cover real news. Do you not want that?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
>you kinda need to subsidize reporting if you want to have any reporting at all
The New York Times and Wall Street Journal don't get any journalist specific funding from the government as far as I know, yet they're able to do investigative journalism just fine it seems.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
The two largest, most storied, and captured by capitalist interests papers in the US can still do journalism? Yeah, fair enough. Nearly every paper in the US is not the NYT or WSJ. And even those two have had to make steep cuts as of late.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
While not deal-breakers, how do we optimally draw two lines:
* What is news? Someone's hot takes on social media? What if a journalist quits the NY Times and starts a solo Substack publication? What if they do the same but post only on Twitter? What if a wealthy indvidual or corporation starts a news org with 10 journalists, otherwise professional, but publishes all brazen disinformation, some dangerous (e.g., dangerous health advice)? What about The Onion?
* How do you prevent government interference? You can structure the funding so its distribution is essentially automatic, such as the OP's tax break for journalist salaries. But once journalism orgs are dependent on the funding, the government can change that. In the US I wonder if the First Amendment would prohibit discrimination based on politics.
> Meta blocked news on Facebook and Instagram in Canada rather than pay under the Online News Act.
Is it a loss to receive less news via social media?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
This sounds great on paper, but the reality is that local news in Canada is dying, if it's not dead already... I wouldn't be surprised if robellus winds up taking most of the money, where it's just a drop in the bucket to them... but big media execs need more ivory back scratchers, amirite?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Good. Only the government knows best.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
I don't want to hear anyone complaining about billionaires lol. You just made a bunch of them. This is how 1%ers are made.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
If 200% of this subsidy went to a single person, you’d just barely make a single billionaire so no, this is not how billionaires(plural) are made.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
1%'s are made from ... journalist salaries?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
This is excellent news (unless you are a stooge of, or advocate for, democratic erosion) because
> Correlations and cluster analyses show that high levels of secure funding for public media systems and strong structural protections for the political and economic independence of those systems are consistently and positively correlated with healthy democracies. ("Funding Democracy: Public Media and Democratic Health in 33 Countries", https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/19401612211060255)
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Maybe they will open a bureau or 2 or 3 in the US and people in the US can access/watch. One can hope:)
We know this will never happen in the US. The one news org in the US that tried to present real news was fully de-funded a year or 2 ago.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Federal funding for the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (PBS, NPR, etc) has happened in the US every single year from 1969 to 2025.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
> Maybe they will open a bureau or 2 or 3 in the US and people in the US can access/watch. One can hope:)
I literally find the news about whatever the heck is going on in the US much better in quality and detail when I get it from CBC, the BBC, France24, DW, reading Le Figaro or El Pais, etc. The CBC in particular does solid analysis of the US from an external perspective, while the contrasting american-originated coverage of the same event often seems so slanted (one way or the other) that it often barely seems to describe the same event.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Wow, just the tax credit alone will cost $500 million. Didn't know Canada had money to spare like that.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
$500m over 5 years = 0.1b/yr, vs ~$600b annual federal budget.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
"Spare?" Like this has no value?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
$100M/year for five years. $100M is not nothing for sure. But it's well within the budgeting capacity for a large nation.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Over five years, so 100MM CAD per year rather than all in one go.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Yes, I understand, still seems like a lot for a relatively small part of the economy
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Is it? The influence of media and journalism on society goes way beyond that.
It's not mean to benefit the "economy", its to support journalism as something that can survive in the country.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
It really is not. Canada's 2025 federal budget was CAD$486.9 billion.
Are you just ignorant or is this you trying to make some kind of insult-joke I'm not American enough to understand?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Over 5 years. Please don’t do the thing anti government program people do where they insinuate or imply that the full cost of a program over years or decades is a one time up front cost.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
One of the dangers of being an English language speaking country located next to the US, in the era of global media, is that if you don't make intentional political moves to support your local media and journalism, is that it'll get steamrolled by American media due to the disparity in size between the economies. And the sheer inertia and might behind something like a Paramount or Fox.
The influence of American media has already been seen extensively in Canada with "maple MAGA" things like the Alberta separatism movement and referendum.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Just make a better product?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
> due to the disparity in size between the economies
Engage with their entire point please
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
And I'd add that for their point to be meaningful they'll also have to be more precise about what "better" means here with respect to media consumption.
To act like the invisible hand will magically create the "best" news is the crudest sort of free-market fundamentalism. It ignores that news readers are not the customers of (ad-funded) media companies but the product. Marketplace success goes to those best at delivering manipulable consumers.
That's very hard to square with the key societal function of news organizations in democracies: producing skeptical, informed citizens able to thoughtfully supervise elected officials and the government.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
So every big corp will make a better product than every small corp? Makes no sense, explain how Apple came to dominate Blackberry or how Amazon came to dominate Walmart then. This isn't about "economies" its about businesses.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Big companies buy smaller better companies to shut them down all the time. This is like, a classic problem in basically every market where there's a small number of major players.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Apple was larger than Research In Motion(the creator of the Blackberry) when the first IPhone came out so I think that kinda fits with the OPs point and not yours.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Probably better if it's a variety of funding sources, particularly in the US where sometimes there is a Trump?
Maybe for Canada it's ok though.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
The article pretty clearly says that it is a variety of sources? It's predominantly supporting tax cuts for journalists (especially in underserved areas). The idea being that private journalism can now exist in a lower cost environment, but still has to be broadly self supporting.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
[flagged]
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
There's no news organization that doesn't have a conflict of interest. ALL news organizations have an interest. Show me one unbiased news org out there. They simply cannot exist because they necessarily must make editorial decisions about what is "newsworthy".
The way this works is tax cuts, which I guess is federal funding, but if a news org can build itself up with these tax cuts, it can help them jump start to a sustainable organization without needing them in the future.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
read the link. It's primarily a tax credit for journalist salaries.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
[flagged]
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Did you even bother to click the link before forming an opinion?
They're lowering income tax on journalist salaries. They're not expanding state owned media, they're essentially lowering taxes for all journalists, making it cheaper to run independent media and reporting.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
They will revoke that tax if they don't like your reporting. It's going to be "you are not a journalist" because you aren't far left.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Can you name a "far left" journalism outlet? They exist, of course, but they are pretty rare. Mostly they publish zines and try to hand out pamphlets. Unicorn Riot, maybe?
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
Did you bother?
They're doing the tax cuts, but also funding and have "independent" third parties determine who is elligible.
“To avoid perceptions of conflict of interest, the government ensured that third parties adjudicate who receives local journalism initiative reporters and who is eligible for the labor tax credit,” Deegan said.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
> have "independent" third parties determine who is elligible
Americans would be shocked to find out how elections are run in Canada.
[3 hidden]5 mins ago
That was my first reaction too, with plenty of examples in so-called public service news. You don't have to go to RT for an example. Several liberal democracies have propaganda captured state subsidized or funded media.
Nor is private any less captured. Fox "News" being the most obvious.
But reading the article I do think there's a good faith and right way to encourage journalism. And it could work.
Likewise, if an independent journalist see net income at a comparable rate to other industries and the bills are paid, in a competitive market they will lower the price of their output to compete.
For those who have been alive longer than social media. Local media was destroyed by large traditional media conglomerates that bought up all of the them during the golden era of traditional media. Now that they aren't profitable and are being kept alive by government how will this solve those problems?
1. What if the government was right-wing and the news produced reflected that - would you still support it? 2. Investigative journalism was birthed in the free market era of yellow journalism, funded by consumers buying newspapers and being served ads - where is this supposed golden age of government funded media that people refer to? 3. For every Fox News, there’s a CNN/MSNBC/. For every WSJ, there’s a WaPo/NYT/LAT/etc. Aka privately funded media results in heavy left wing skew - what’s the gap that government funded media fills? 4. Government funded media is by definition propaganda - that doesn’t concern you? 5. Of the government is paying journalists’ salaries, how does that reduce conflict of interest in holding higher ups accountable more so than for journalists and privately funded outlets? Wouldn’t both be hesitant to go after their respective bosses?
There is no easy solution. The best is to leave it up to people to choose their sources.
Unfortunately, Canada is moving in wrong directions. Canadians haven't lived in EU to understand where the policies of their government is leading to.
Not saying the government here doesn't have a problem with overspending, but it's perhaps not as bad as you might think
Just like public ownership of critical infrastructure, it doesn't matter what it costs, we should own it collectively.
What are some countries where you think they're doing a good job and going in the right direction?
All the infrastructure decaying today was built with the ample tax revenue back then, until Thatcherism, trickle down and starve the beast crap ideology corrupted everything
This isn’t Canada moving in any direction, the CBC has been around and publically funded for decades.
We shouldn't pretend that there's no political risk, no matter if it's structured as a tax break or direct ownership: every time you tie the well-being of journalists to government policy, you inject some bias into the process.
However, journalism as such is not financially sustainable in the era of internet clickbait and AI slop, so you kinda need to subsidize reporting if you want to have any reporting at all. Otherwise, all the local news you're gonna get are gonna be Facebook gossip, fake stories engineered for clicks, and paid PR pieces.
Like, yeah, BBC minces their words when it comes to criticizing government policy, but they can also afford to send real journalists to cover real news. Do you not want that?
The New York Times and Wall Street Journal don't get any journalist specific funding from the government as far as I know, yet they're able to do investigative journalism just fine it seems.
* What is news? Someone's hot takes on social media? What if a journalist quits the NY Times and starts a solo Substack publication? What if they do the same but post only on Twitter? What if a wealthy indvidual or corporation starts a news org with 10 journalists, otherwise professional, but publishes all brazen disinformation, some dangerous (e.g., dangerous health advice)? What about The Onion?
* How do you prevent government interference? You can structure the funding so its distribution is essentially automatic, such as the OP's tax break for journalist salaries. But once journalism orgs are dependent on the funding, the government can change that. In the US I wonder if the First Amendment would prohibit discrimination based on politics.
> Meta blocked news on Facebook and Instagram in Canada rather than pay under the Online News Act.
Is it a loss to receive less news via social media?
> Correlations and cluster analyses show that high levels of secure funding for public media systems and strong structural protections for the political and economic independence of those systems are consistently and positively correlated with healthy democracies. ("Funding Democracy: Public Media and Democratic Health in 33 Countries", https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/19401612211060255)
We know this will never happen in the US. The one news org in the US that tried to present real news was fully de-funded a year or 2 ago.
I literally find the news about whatever the heck is going on in the US much better in quality and detail when I get it from CBC, the BBC, France24, DW, reading Le Figaro or El Pais, etc. The CBC in particular does solid analysis of the US from an external perspective, while the contrasting american-originated coverage of the same event often seems so slanted (one way or the other) that it often barely seems to describe the same event.
Are you just ignorant or is this you trying to make some kind of insult-joke I'm not American enough to understand?
The influence of American media has already been seen extensively in Canada with "maple MAGA" things like the Alberta separatism movement and referendum.
Engage with their entire point please
To act like the invisible hand will magically create the "best" news is the crudest sort of free-market fundamentalism. It ignores that news readers are not the customers of (ad-funded) media companies but the product. Marketplace success goes to those best at delivering manipulable consumers.
That's very hard to square with the key societal function of news organizations in democracies: producing skeptical, informed citizens able to thoughtfully supervise elected officials and the government.
Maybe for Canada it's ok though.
The way this works is tax cuts, which I guess is federal funding, but if a news org can build itself up with these tax cuts, it can help them jump start to a sustainable organization without needing them in the future.
They're lowering income tax on journalist salaries. They're not expanding state owned media, they're essentially lowering taxes for all journalists, making it cheaper to run independent media and reporting.
They're doing the tax cuts, but also funding and have "independent" third parties determine who is elligible.
“To avoid perceptions of conflict of interest, the government ensured that third parties adjudicate who receives local journalism initiative reporters and who is eligible for the labor tax credit,” Deegan said.
Americans would be shocked to find out how elections are run in Canada.
Nor is private any less captured. Fox "News" being the most obvious.
But reading the article I do think there's a good faith and right way to encourage journalism. And it could work.