When I first started reading seminal works in Distributed Computing, I picked up the original (The Part-time Parliament) and it started off pretty well with the made up story of finding the algorithm as a manuscript from an archeological dig.
The original paper then quickly becomes super convoluted by continuing to explain the algorithm by overextending that allegory. By the mid point of it I felt pretty exhausted.
It was then I learnt that the original paper was lying in limbo for nearly a decade until it was finally published.
Then at a conference, Lamport got tired of people telling him his original was difficult to grasp and so came this simplified explanation.
I still have my notes on the paper somewhere in my Obsidian. I should publish those.
+1 to this. I am on Assignment 3D (dealing with log compaction in Raft). I have learnt more about Distributed Systems just by "auditing" this course.
For Paxos, I also recommend reading Paxos v Raft, Have we reached consensus on distributed consensus ? by Heidi Howard et al. It explains Multi-paxos by using the style and abstractions from the Raft paper, which makes it much more understandable. Paxos can be intimidating but this was the paper that made it click for me.
I highly recommend doing the labs from 6.824.
sangeeth96 [3 hidden]5 mins ago
are you by chance watching the spring 2020 version? [1]
> The Paxos algorithm for implementing a fault-tolerant distributed system
has been regarded as difficult to understand, perhaps because the original
presentation was Greek to many readers.
Ha! That's very clever, author. You clearly have a similar sense of humor to...oh, it's Leslie Lamport again.
happypappy123 [3 hidden]5 mins ago
Just get llms to explain it to you; it's so much easier.
HN.zip
The original paper then quickly becomes super convoluted by continuing to explain the algorithm by overextending that allegory. By the mid point of it I felt pretty exhausted.
It was then I learnt that the original paper was lying in limbo for nearly a decade until it was finally published.
Then at a conference, Lamport got tired of people telling him his original was difficult to grasp and so came this simplified explanation.
I still have my notes on the paper somewhere in my Obsidian. I should publish those.
For Paxos, I also recommend reading Paxos v Raft, Have we reached consensus on distributed consensus ? by Heidi Howard et al. It explains Multi-paxos by using the style and abstractions from the Raft paper, which makes it much more understandable. Paxos can be intimidating but this was the paper that made it click for me.
I highly recommend doing the labs from 6.824.
[1]: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLrw6a1wE39_tb2fErI4-W...
Ha! That's very clever, author. You clearly have a similar sense of humor to...oh, it's Leslie Lamport again.